Doc­u­ments and appeals

How to challenge a notary’s refusal: documents and court remedies

If a notary in Kyiv refuses to certify a con­tract or power of at­tor­ney, do not start with a generic com­plaint. Obtain a rea­soned order, compare it with the doc­u­ments you sub­mit­ted and decide whether to remove the ob­sta­cle, chal­lenge the refusal or protect a prop­er­ty right.

Legal dossier prepared for reading the guide
Current
8 No­vem­ber 2026
Reading
5 min
Focus
Kyiv
Briefly

What you should know

  • Ask for a written order: an oral con­ver­sa­tion does not dis­close every ground for refusal or replace the reasons in writing.
  • The notary issues a refusal order within 3 working days. This is not the period for filing a court claim.
  • If a proper doc­u­ment is missing, first con­sid­er ob­tain­ing or cor­rect­ing it; a court chal­lenge is not always nec­es­sary.
  • A com­plaint about office man­age­ment does not replace a court remedy. The claim, parties and court depend on the right af­fect­ed.
Steps

From a written order to an appropriate claim

  1. Record the refusalObtain the order and keep ev­i­dence of your ap­pli­ca­tion.
  2. Compare the doc­u­mentsCheck the stated reasons against what you sub­mit­ted.
  3. Choose the remedySep­a­rate doc­u­ment cor­rec­tion from a chal­lenge or a dispute about rights.
  4. Check the outcomeAfter judg­ment, es­tab­lish which no­tar­i­al steps are still re­quired.

When this is needed

This guide helps if you applied for a spe­cif­ic no­tar­i­al act and re­ceived a refusal you dis­agree with. First dis­tin­guish a final refusal from advice, a request to bring another doc­u­ment or post­pone­ment of the act. Ask which doc­u­ment or legal ob­sta­cle pre­vents com­ple­tion and, if the act is refused, request a written order.

Ed­u­ca­tion­al example for Kyiv: an owner is prepar­ing to sell an apart­ment through a rep­re­sen­ta­tive. The notary con­sid­ers that the power of at­tor­ney does not au­tho­rize the agreed act. Saying “the power of at­tor­ney is valid” does not resolve the issue: compare its scope, the pro­posed con­tract and the order’s rea­son­ing. A new, ap­pro­pri­ate power of at­tor­ney may be more prac­ti­cal than lit­i­ga­tion; if the nec­es­sary au­thor­i­ty already existed, assess whether that spe­cif­ic refusal was lawful.

This pro­ce­dure differs from chal­leng­ing a notary’s en­force­ment en­dorse­ment. If the notary acted as a state reg­is­trar, es­tab­lish sep­a­rate­ly what is being chal­lenged: refusal of a no­tar­i­al act, a reg­is­tra­tion de­ci­sion or another person’s right.

What deadline or procedure applies

Article 49 of the Law of Ukraine on No­tari­at pro­vides grounds for refusal. In par­tic­u­lar, you cannot demand an act con­trary to law or without the nec­es­sary doc­u­ments. At the person’s request, reasons must be given in writing with an ex­pla­na­tion of how to chal­lenge the refusal; the notary issues the order within 3 working days. Keep the ap­pli­ca­tion, proof of de­liv­ery and the date you re­ceived the order.

Under Article 50, a refusal is chal­lenged in court. An or­ga­ni­za­tion­al com­plaint about the notary’s work does not set aside the order or replace an ap­pro­pri­ate court claim. Check the time limit, ju­ris­dic­tion and ter­ri­to­r­i­al venue against the sub­stance of the dispute; the order-is­suance period must not be treated as the claim-filing period.

Not every dispute re­quires a claim against the notary. If you dispute the rights of a buyer, heir or another par­tic­i­pant, the proper parties and remedy may differ. A judg­ment de­clar­ing a refusal un­law­ful also does not au­to­mat­i­cal­ly certify a con­tract or es­tab­lish own­er­ship.

How to act step by step

  1. Make a clear request for the spe­cif­ic no­tar­i­al act and record the doc­u­ments you sup­plied. If it is refused, request a written order and keep proof of your ap­pli­ca­tion.
  2. Read the reasons: what is missing, which rule was applied, and whether the doc­u­ments and au­thor­i­ty are de­scribed cor­rect­ly. Request a copy or clar­i­fi­ca­tion of unclear wording; do not rely solely on an oral summary.
  3. Con­sid­er the prac­ti­cal route. Obtain a missing doc­u­ment, clarify au­thor­i­ty or correct an actual error if that removes the reason. If the ob­sta­cle is un­jus­ti­fied, prepare an answer to each ground for refusal.
  4. Iden­ti­fy the right re­quir­ing pro­tec­tion, the proper parties and court. For­mu­late the claim, attach the order and ev­i­dence of the doc­u­ments sub­mit­ted, and check the court fee and filing pro­ce­dure. After judg­ment, es­tab­lish the re­main­ing no­tar­i­al steps.

For a prop­er­ty trans­ac­tion, retain cor­re­spon­dence with the other party, the draft con­tract and payment terms. Do not trans­fer money merely because someone promis­es to “quickly over­turn” the refusal. Before a resched­uled trans­ac­tion, check whether reg­istry in­for­ma­tion or the rep­re­sen­ta­tive’s au­thor­i­ty has changed.

What to check before filing

Check that the order ad­dress­es your actual request, gives spe­cif­ic legal grounds, and ac­cu­rate­ly re­flects whether the nec­es­sary doc­u­ments were before the notary when the refusal was issued. A doc­u­ment ob­tained later may allow a fresh ap­pli­ca­tion but does not itself prove the earlier order was un­law­ful.

If the refusal con­cerns an un­proven family re­la­tion­ship in an in­her­i­tance case, sep­a­rate­ly review the con­di­tions for es­tab­lish­ing the fact of kinship and whether the doc­u­ments can be re­stored.

Check whether the chosen claim ac­tu­al­ly reme­dies the breach. Do not ask the court to replace the notary in an act within the notary’s com­pe­tence. If there is a sep­a­rate dispute about the apart­ment or con­tract, assess it to­geth­er with the refusal rather than dis­guis­ing it as a com­plaint. For costs, use the ex­pla­na­tion of the court fee for a claim, check­ing the type of relief sought.

When to consult a lawyer

Legal review is useful when a trans­ac­tion is falling through, a deposit is in­volved, dis­pos­al re­stric­tions apply, a rep­re­sen­ta­tive acts under a power of at­tor­ney, a child’s rights are af­fect­ed or com­pet­ing prop­er­ty rights exist. A lawyer should assess both defects in the order and whether the in­tend­ed outcome can law­ful­ly be ob­tained.

For a sit­u­a­tion in Kyiv, prepare the order, power of at­tor­ney, draft con­tract and copies of the doc­u­ments sub­mit­ted. A con­sul­ta­tion on prop­er­ty trans­ac­tion support can es­tab­lish whether cor­rect­ing the file is suf­fi­cient, whether court pro­tec­tion is needed and what risks would remain after judg­ment. This guide does not guar­an­tee per­for­mance of the act or cover every special re­stric­tion on the par­tic­u­lar trans­ac­tion.

Responding to refusal or inaction

Po­ten­tial­ly suit­able routes depend on the subject of your request. These are sep­a­rate options, not a manda­to­ry se­quence of in­sti­tu­tions to ap­proach.

Evidence to keep before applying

  • A written, rea­soned de­ci­sion re­fus­ing a spe­cif­ic no­tar­i­al act.
  • Copies of the doc­u­ments sub­mit­ted, ev­i­dence of the ap­pli­ca­tion and cor­re­spon­dence about the reason for refusal.
  • Clarifying or resolving the cause

    A doc­u­ment or au­thor­i­ty to act is missing, or there is a cor­rectable error.

    Compare the reasons in the de­ci­sion with the doc­u­ments sub­mit­ted. If the ob­sta­cle can be re­solved, clarify which doc­u­ment is needed before ap­ply­ing again.

  • Challenging a refusal in court

    You believe the refusal is un­law­ful and need court pro­tec­tion.

    Iden­ti­fy the in­fringed right, the proper parties, the claim and the court. A prop­er­ty rights dispute may require dif­fer­ent parties; setting aside a refusal does not au­to­mat­i­cal­ly es­tab­lish own­er­ship.

  • Justice authority

    The issue con­cerns the or­gan­i­sa­tion of work or pro­fes­sion­al mis­con­duct.

    Check the justice au­thor­i­ty’s powers in re­la­tion to the spe­cif­ic com­plaint. Such a com­plaint does not replace a court chal­lenge to the law­ful­ness of the refusal.

The dead­line for the notary to issue a de­ci­sion differs from the court filing dead­line. Do not wait until cor­re­spon­dence has ended to check the court dead­line.

We can help review the chal­lenge pro­ce­dure, dead­lines and ev­i­dence, and prepare a request or court doc­u­ments for your cir­cum­stances.

Discuss a challenge with a lawyer

How to obtain written reasons for a refusal

Request for a written refusal resolution

Ukrain­ian example and blank for a person who re­quest­ed a spe­cif­ic no­tar­i­al act and re­ceived a refusal. The request con­cerns a written res­o­lu­tion; it does not prove un­law­ful­ness or au­to­mat­i­cal­ly secure per­for­mance of the act. The notary’s name and address, per­son­al details and events are fic­tion­al; replace them with your own ver­i­fied in­for­ma­tion.

The doc­u­ment text and files are in Ukrain­ian. Ex­pla­na­tions are pro­vid­ed in the se­lect­ed site lan­guage.

Educational document context

Educational scenario

За­яв­ник звер­нув­ся до при­ва­тно­го но­та­рі­у­са для за­свід­че­н­ня справ­жно­сті під­пи­су на заяві. За умо­ва­ми при­кла­ду но­та­рі­ус усно від­мо­вив; пи­сьмо­вої по­ста­но­ви за­яв­ник ще не отри­мав. Він про­сить офор­ми­ти при­чи­ни та по­ря­док оскар­же­н­ня, не ви­ма­га­ю­чи на­пе­ред ви­зна­ти від­мо­ву не­за­кон­ною.

Example assumptions

  • Особа вже звер­ну­ла­ся щодо кон­кре­тної но­та­рі­аль­ної дії та отри­ма­ла від­мо­ву, а не лише по­пе­ре­дню кон­суль­та­цію чи пе­ре­лік по­трі­бних до­ку­мен­тів.
  • Адре­сат — той самий но­та­рі­ус, до якого особа звер­ну­ла­ся; за­яв­ник діє осо­би­сто.
  • Ім’я но­та­рі­у­са, осо­би­ста адреса за­яв­ни­ка, адреса ро­бо­чо­го місця, до­ку­мен­ти та події в при­кла­ді пов­ні­стю ви­га­да­ні.
  • За­зна­ча­ють лише до­ку­мен­ти, які фа­кти­чно по­да­ва­ли но­та­рі­у­су, та до­да­тки, які справ­ді до­да­ють до вимоги.

Scope of application

  • Не є скар­гою до органу юсти­ції, по­зо­вом чи заявою про оскар­же­н­ня ви­ко­нав­чо­го напису.
  • Не вста­нов­лює права на вчи­не­н­ня но­та­рі­аль­ної дії та не за­мі­нює від­су­тніх до­ку­мен­тів.
  • Не ви­зна­чає та не зу­пи­няє строк су­до­во­го за­хи­сту; по­ря­док і строк оці­ню­ють окремо за ха­ра­кте­ром спору.

Completed educational example

Ed­u­ca­tion­al ma­te­r­i­al: the ap­pli­cants, their per­son­al ad­dress­es, iden­ti­fiers, doc­u­ments and events are wholly fic­tion­al; doc­u­ment numbers are il­lus­tra­tive. The names of real au­thor­i­ties are in­clud­ed only for the defined ed­u­ca­tion­al sce­nario; this example does not de­scribe their actual de­ci­sions. Do not file it as a com­plet­ed doc­u­ment.

Адре­сат: При­ва­тно­му но­та­рі­у­су Ки­їв­сько­го мі­сько­го но­та­рі­аль­но­го округу На­вчаль­ній Олені Пе­трів­ні (пов­ні­стю ви­га­да­на особа).

Адреса адре­са­та: 01001, м. Київ, вул. На­вчаль­на, буд. 40 (ви­га­да­на адреса, не для ли­сту­ва­н­ня).

За­яв­ник: На­вчаль­ний Андрій Іва­но­вич (ви­га­да­на особа). Місце про­жи­ва­н­ня та адреса для від­по­віді: 01001, м. Київ, вул. На­вчаль­на, буд. 18, кв. 3 (ви­га­да­на осо­би­ста адреса, не для ли­сту­ва­н­ня).

Вимога про оформлення письмової постанови про відмову у вчиненні нотаріальної дії

Моє звер­не­н­ня: Заява від 9 ли­сто­па­да 2026 року, вру­че­на осо­би­сто того самого дня; на­вчаль­на копія з від­мі­ткою про одер­жа­н­ня. За­пи­та­на но­та­рі­аль­на дія: За­свід­че­н­ня справ­жно­сті мого під­пи­су на заяві (зміст заяви не від­тво­рю­є­ться).

Під час звер­не­н­ня подано: Заяву та проєкт до­ку­мен­та; до­ку­мент, що по­свід­чує особу, пред’явлено для огляду (ре­аль­них іден­ти­фі­ка­то­рів не на­ве­де­но).

Об­ста­ви­ни по­ві­дом­ле­н­ня від­мо­ви: 9 ли­сто­па­да 2026 року но­та­рі­ус усно по­ві­до­ми­ла про від­мо­ву; по­ста­но­ви й пи­сьмо­вих мо­ти­вів не надано.

Від­по­від­но до статті 49 Закону Укра­ї­ни «Про но­та­рі­а­т» прошу ви­кла­сти при­чи­ни від­мо­ви в пи­сьмо­вій формі та роз’яснити по­ря­док її оскар­же­н­ня.

Прошу
  1. Офор­ми­ти по­ста­но­ву про від­мо­ву щодо за­зна­че­ної но­та­рі­аль­ної дії з ви­кла­де­н­ням кон­кре­тних причин та по­си­ла­н­ням на норми за­ко­но­дав­ства.
  2. За­зна­чи­ти в по­ста­но­ві по­ря­док і строки оскар­же­н­ня з по­си­ла­н­ням на від­по­від­ні норми за­ко­но­дав­ства.
  3. Надати мені по­ста­но­ву обра­ним нижче спосо­бом.

Спосіб одер­жа­н­ня: Поштою на за­зна­че­ну вище адресу за­яв­ни­ка (на­вчаль­на адреса не для від­прав­ле­н­ня).

До­да­тки:

  1. Копія заяви від 9 ли­сто­па­да 2026 року з умов­ною від­мі­ткою про одер­жа­н­ня — 1 арк.
  2. Копія про­є­кту до­ку­мен­та, щодо якого про­си­ли за­свід­чи­ти підпис, — 1 арк.; усі ма­те­рі­а­ли на­вчаль­ні

Дата: 11 ли­сто­па­да 2026 року (на­вчаль­на дата). Підпис: підпис у на­вчаль­но­му при­кла­ді не від­тво­рю­є­ться.

What to check when completing the template

Requested act
Iden­ti­fy one spe­cif­ic act and the orig­i­nal ap­pli­ca­tion, rather than simply “pro­cess­ing doc­u­ments”.
Materials supplied
List only what you ac­tu­al­ly sup­plied; do not retroac­tive­ly add missing doc­u­ments.
Refusal
State the date, method of com­mu­ni­ca­tion and ex­pla­na­tions re­ceived without as­sum­ing un­law­ful­ness.
Delivery and attachments
Choose an ap­pro­pri­ate re­sponse method, sign and date the request, and retain only at­tach­ments ac­tu­al­ly en­closed. Keep proof of sub­mit­ting the request and re­ceiv­ing the res­o­lu­tion.
The same notary
Address the same notary to whom you sub­mit­ted the ap­pli­ca­tion. Check the name, no­tar­i­al dis­trict or office and address; do not send the request to an ar­bi­trary justice au­thor­i­ty.
Court deadline
Re­quest­ing written reasons should not be treated as sus­pend­ing a court dead­line.
View the blank template

Адре­сат: [ПІБ но­та­рі­у­са, но­та­рі­аль­ний округ або най­ме­ну­ва­н­ня дер­жав­ної но­та­рі­аль­ної кон­то­ри].

Адреса адре­са­та: [Пе­ре­ві­ре­на адреса ро­бо­чо­го місця но­та­рі­у­са або кон­то­ри].

За­яв­ник: [Прі­зви­ще, ім’я, по ба­тько­ві за­яв­ни­ка]. Місце про­жи­ва­н­ня та адреса для від­по­віді: [Місце про­жи­ва­н­ня та по­што­ва адреса для від­по­віді з ін­де­ксом].

Вимога про оформлення письмової постанови про відмову у вчиненні нотаріальної дії

Моє звер­не­н­ня: [Дата, спосіб звер­не­н­ня та ре­кві­зи­ти заяви за на­яв­но­сті]. За­пи­та­на но­та­рі­аль­на дія: [Кон­кре­тна но­та­рі­аль­на дія, про яку про­си­ли].

Під час звер­не­н­ня подано: [Пе­ре­лік фа­кти­чно по­да­них до­ку­мен­тів та спосіб їх по­да­н­ня].

Об­ста­ви­ни по­ві­дом­ле­н­ня від­мо­ви: [Дата, спосіб по­ві­дом­ле­н­ня від­мо­ви та отри­ма­ні по­ясне­н­ня].

Від­по­від­но до статті 49 Закону Укра­ї­ни «Про но­та­рі­а­т» прошу ви­кла­сти при­чи­ни від­мо­ви в пи­сьмо­вій формі та роз’яснити по­ря­док її оскар­же­н­ня.

Прошу
  1. Офор­ми­ти по­ста­но­ву про від­мо­ву щодо за­зна­че­ної но­та­рі­аль­ної дії з ви­кла­де­н­ням кон­кре­тних причин та по­си­ла­н­ням на норми за­ко­но­дав­ства.
  2. За­зна­чи­ти в по­ста­но­ві по­ря­док і строки оскар­же­н­ня з по­си­ла­н­ням на від­по­від­ні норми за­ко­но­дав­ства.
  3. Надати мені по­ста­но­ву обра­ним нижче спосо­бом.

Спосіб одер­жа­н­ня: [Ба­жа­ний за­кон­ний спосіб одер­жа­н­ня по­ста­но­ви та по­трі­бні для цього кон­та­кти].

До­да­тки:

  1. [Копія пер­ві­сної заяви та кіль­кість ар­ку­шів, якщо до­да­є­ться]
  2. [Інші фа­кти­чно додані ма­те­рі­а­ли, їх ре­кві­зи­ти та кіль­кість ар­ку­шів; за від­су­тно­сті ви­лу­чіть від­по­від­ний пункт]

Дата: [Дата скла­да­н­ня та під­пи­са­н­ня]. Підпис: [Вла­сно­ру­чний або на­ле­жний еле­ктрон­ний підпис за­яв­ни­ка].

Files to read and complete

PDF pre­serves the layout. DOCX con­tains a tem­plate with named blanks. Check your own cir­cum­stances and at­tach­ments before use.

Sources and review

Checked

Documents

What to prepare

  • The written refusal order and ev­i­dence of when you re­ceived it.
  • Your ap­pli­ca­tion for the spe­cif­ic no­tar­i­al act and proof that you applied.
  • Copies of the doc­u­ments in the exact form sub­mit­ted to the notary.
  • Ev­i­dence of the rep­re­sen­ta­tive’s au­thor­i­ty, prop­er­ty rights or grounds for in­her­i­tance, de­pend­ing on the act re­quest­ed.
  • Cor­re­spon­dence about ad­di­tion­al doc­u­ments, in­sti­tu­tion­al replies and proof of pay­ments where rel­e­vant to the reason for refusal.
  • A chronol­o­gy, pro­posed claims, and doc­u­ments on the court fee or a basis for ex­emp­tion.
Risks

Common mistakes

  • Asking a court simply to issue an in­her­i­tance cer­tifi­cate in place of the notary.
  • Treat­ing every request for an ad­di­tion­al doc­u­ment as un­law­ful without check­ing its legal basis.
  • Naming the notary as de­fen­dant in every in­her­i­tance or con­tract dispute.
  • Waiting for a reply to an ad­min­is­tra­tive com­plaint without check­ing the time limits for pro­tect­ing your right in court.

Official sources

Prepared
This ma­te­r­i­al was pre­pared for the website’s ref­er­ence section based on of­fi­cial sources.
Control
Before pub­li­ca­tion, the editors check legal state­ments against the cited of­fi­cial sources and the date they were current.
Important
This guide is in­for­ma­tion­al. A de­ci­sion re­quires review of the doc­u­ments, dead­lines, and factual cir­cum­stances.

Current as of . The ma­te­r­i­al depends on the doc­u­ments and cir­cum­stances of the spe­cif­ic case.

Frequently asked questions

Frequently asked questions

Should I obtain a written refusal order?

Request it if you have been refused an act. The order should iden­ti­fy the spe­cif­ic act, reasons, legal grounds and chal­lenge pro­ce­dure. An oral ex­pla­na­tion or a request to bring another doc­u­ment does not provide the same basis for review.

Must I file a claim within 3 working days?

No. That period con­cerns the notary issuing the refusal order. The time limit for court pro­tec­tion must be checked sep­a­rate­ly ac­cord­ing to the claim, the right af­fect­ed and the cir­cum­stances. Do not post­pone that check until cor­re­spon­dence ends.

Is a complaint to a justice authority sufficient?

An or­ga­ni­za­tion­al or pro­fes­sion­al breach and the law­ful­ness of a refusal are dif­fer­ent matters. A com­plaint to a justice au­thor­i­ty does not replace a court chal­lenge under Article 50 and does not itself de­ter­mine a prop­er­ty dispute.

Will the property become mine if the refusal is set aside?

Setting aside a refusal does not au­to­mat­i­cal­ly confer own­er­ship or produce a cer­tifi­cate. You must con­sid­er the terms of the judg­ment, resolve other ob­sta­cles and com­plete the nec­es­sary no­tar­i­al acts.

Should I approach another notary in Kyiv?

That does not bypass a lawful ob­sta­cle. Another notary will also check the doc­u­ments and au­thor­i­ty. If the reason is a dispute about rights or a re­stric­tion on dis­pos­al, resolve that issue first; if a doc­u­ment is missing, obtain it.

Free initial con­sul­ta­tion

Need help with: Challenging a notary’s refusal?

Briefly de­scribe the sit­u­a­tion. We will check which doc­u­ments and dead­lines are crit­i­cal in your case.

  • a phone number or brief de­scrip­tion is enough
  • after the first contact, the next step should be clear
  • during the first con­ver­sa­tion, we will clarify the doc­u­ments needed and the scope of help

Your query stays on this device